One of the most successful franchises of the last decades, an entire generation grew up with the Harry Potter books and movies. However, as time has passed, fans have come to view this series in a different light. Many aspects that were initially considered magical and fantastic have become questionable. For example, Albus Dumbledore was supposed to be a heroic figure in the series.
Dumbledore was the wisest and most powerful wizard in the books, and his character inspired many fans. Still, the more Harry Potter fans rewatch the movies, Dumbledore seems more of a villain than the hero he was supposed to be.
10/10 Dumbledore lets Harry compete in the Triwizard Tournament
During harry potter and the goblet of fire, the dynamics at Hogwarts change when the students discover that the school will host the Triwizard Tournament. As exciting as the event is, the only competitors are adults because the tasks are considered too dangerous for younger students. Dumbledore even creates an age line around the Goblet of Fire, so the other students won’t try to claim it as champion.
However, Barty Crouch Jr. modifies the Goblet of Fire and finds a way to include Harry in the competition. When Harry’s name appears as the second Hogwarts champion, the entire school is distraught, but the committee allows this to happen. Before the fifth book, Dumbledore is introduced as having a lot of influence in the Ministry and other major wizarding associations, so it doesn’t make any sense that he would allow Harry to compete.
9/10 Dumbledore actively avoided Harry during his fifth year
After Harry saw Voldemort rise to power, he had to spend the entire summer isolated from the wizarding community on Privet Drive. Upset by Cedric’s death and worried about Voldemort’s return, Harry wants to speak with Dumbledore to better understand the situation.
However, the headmaster doesn’t take a moment to discuss anything with Harry. Although Dumbledore is supposed to be a guiding figure for the Gryffindor boy, he completely abandons Harry. Later, Dumbledore admits that he was afraid to see Voldemort in Harry’s eyes, which makes him even worse. On top of that, the consequence of the headmaster neglecting Harry was Sirius’ death.
8/10 Dumbledore encouraged Harry and Hermione to travel back in time
In Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Harry not only discovers that he has a godfather, but also that Sirius was wrongfully sent to Azkaban for the murder of Peter Pettigrew. However, the Dementors manage to imprison Sirius when Lupine loses control after turning into a werewolf.
Since Hermione had been using the Time Turner that year, Dumbledore subtly suggests that they could save Sirius’ life by turning back time. This is not only incredibly irresponsible, as it could have dire consequences for the timeline, but it also shows how little Dumbledore tries to protect the students from him.
7/10 Dumbledore constantly showed favoritism
Ever since Harry arrived at Hogwarts, it was more than clear that he was Dumbledore’s favorite student. While it makes sense that the Headmaster had a strong emotional attachment to Harry, he should have kept a more sensible attitude.
In Harry potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, Dumbledore actively found a way for Gryffindor to win the House Cup, even though Slytherin was winning at the time. There’s no doubt that Harry had been incredibly heroic, but taking victory away from an entire house was incredibly unfair. This shows how Dumbledore is one of the worst role models in Harry Potter.
6/10 Dumbledore lets terrible things happen at Hogwarts
Albus Dumbledore is supposed to be the best headmaster at Hogwarts, but he’s actually very negligent. Despite the fact that he means well for his staff and his students, he often lets many terrible things happen at his school. For example, he lets Snape get away with bullying most of the students and constantly favoring Slytherin house.
As the head of the school, it would make sense for Dumbledore to limit this type of behavior among his teachers. On top of that, he allows Professor Trelawney to scare the children with false prophecies. When school security is in jeopardy, he doesn’t really try to fix it. Dumbledore does not provide the bare minimum of security for Hogwarts students.
5/10 Dumbledore forced Snape to be a double spy
When Snape confesses to Dumbledore that he had given Voldemort information about the prophecy, the Hogwarts headmaster immediately recruits Snape as one of his most loyal allies. Snape wants to make up for Lily’s death and help her son defeat the dark wizard, but Dumbledore takes it too far.
There’s no question that Snape’s actions were appalling, but Dumbledore has no problem putting the Potions professor in horrible situations. Snape becomes Dumbledore’s double spy, a very dangerous position that ends up getting him killed by Nagini. On top of that, Dumbledore convinces Snape to kill him to protect Draco Malfoy, which is also horrible.
4/10 Dumbledore lets Harry grow up with the Dursleys
When Harry’s parents are killed by Voldemort and the dark wizard disappears, Dumbledore decides to leave Harry at the Dursleys’ house, going against Professor McGonagall’s warning. The Dursleys were clearly a terrible family, but Dumbledore still leaves Harry with them.
Although Dumbledore tried to protect Harry with this decision, it’s more than clear that he prioritized Harry being alive over his emotional development. Any wizarding family would have adopted Harry, but Dumbledore thought it best to let him live with some of the more terrible Muggles. This is even worse than some of the worst things Death Eaters ever did.
3/10 Dumbledore’s obsession with the Deathly Hallows never abated
As readers discover throughout the sixth and seventh books, Dumbledore is not as innocent as people would like to believe. The headmaster had a dark past where he had been tempted by the Dark Arts. When he was younger, Dumbledore was obsessed with the Deathly Hallows, which are supposed to provide immortality.
As much as Dumbledore tried to stay on the path of good, it’s obvious that this obsession never stopped. He asked Harry’s father to analyze the Invisibility Cloak, used the Slytherin ring as soon as he had it in his possession, and kept the Elder Wand after defeating Grindelwald instead of destroying him.
2/10 Dumbledore worked with Grindelwald to start a war
After Dumbledore graduated from Hogwarts, he became friends with his neighbor’s relative, Gellert Grindelwald. This wizard had pure-blood ideas about the Wizarding World, and believed that Muggles should be forced into servitude. Dumbledore’s arrogance and his hatred of Muggles who hurt his sister led him to believe in Grindelwald’s ideals.
Dumbledore’s path to evil ended with Ariana’s death, after Aberforth, Grindelwald, and Dumbledore had a deadly fight. Although the Headmaster eventually recognized how wrong he was, this was one of Dumbledore’s biggest mistakes throughout.Harry Potter.
1/10 Dumbledore trained Harry to face Voldemort and die
Dumbledore was on the right side of history, fighting Voldemort and Grindelwald to protect Muggles and all innocent lives. However, it seems that Dumbledore believed that the end justified the means, which is a very evil way of thinking.
Dumbledore repeatedly made utilitarian decisions that, while protecting the world, could seriously hurt someone. In Harry’s case, Dumbledore went to great lengths to prepare him to accept his fate and die at Voldemort’s hands. However, he had no consideration for the teenager.
NEXT: 10 Times Harry Potter Acted Like A Villain