Thanks to how dominant the DC Extended Universe (DCEU) and Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) movies are these days, some jaded viewers tend to remember the supposedly better days of the superhero genre. Through nostalgia and their own merits, these movies are often held up as examples that current superhero movies should follow.
The truth, however, is that these movies are not as good as their most ardent fans would claim. While not mean or offensive, these superhero movies get more credit and praise than they really deserve. Sometimes fans of these movies are understandably sentimental about their favorites, or try too hard to be contrary.
10/10 The Dark Knight Rises was the tepid end of a groundbreaking trilogy
The dark knight trilogy changed DC Comics adaptations and superhero movies forever. Each chapter left its mark on the genre and pop culture of the late 2000s. Case in point: the dark knight rises he is fondly remembered for giving Christian Bale’s Batman a concrete resolution and for having some of the best moments in the Batman movies.
Nevertheless, the dark knight rises was missing Batman Begins‘stunning visuals, and didn’t quite get to The dark knight‘shigh dramatic bar. And what is more, The dark knight rises’ attempts at social commentary were perfunctory at best and mishandled at worst. the dark knight rises it’s good, but it’s still the weakest link in an iconic trilogy.
9/10 The man of steel was better in theory than in execution
for the portentous Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice Y Zack Snyder’s Justice League are, many consider Iron Man as Snyder’s best and most accessible DCEU movie. Fans loved Superman’s gritty modernization told through Snyder’s style. Nevertheless, Iron Man‘s ideas and themes worked best separately.
Iron Man it examined how Superman would react to the modern world and vice versa. The movie also showed just how destructive Superman’s existence would be. These concepts were ambitious. but together they did Iron Man a morose deconstruction of a shared superhero universe just getting started, and excessive sensory overload.
8/10 The Punisher (2004) was just another vigilante action movie
Thomas Jane is one of the most underrated action stars of his generation. Jane’s fans consider his turn as Frank Castle in The Punisher as one of the best testimonials to his unrecognized abilities. Jane and her co-stars gave funny and memorable performances, but they were in the service of a unremarkable vigilante movie.
The PunisherThe biggest flaw of was how disappointingly tame it was for an R-rated adaptation of a violent comic. The Punisher It wasn’t the worst vigilante movie, but it wasn’t nearly as brutal or compelling as later adaptations. Jane’s portrayal of the controversial vigilante Punisher was best utilized in The Punisher‘sunofficial Sequel, Dirty clothes.
7/10 The cast of The Amazing Spider-Man aged better than the actual movie
The amazing Spider Man it is credited with introducing a new generation to Spider-Man. Most of this praise was reserved for the stars of the reboot, specifically Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone. But beyond its talented cast, The amazing Spider Man it had little to offer beyond a formulaic superhero origin story.
The actors and some fun action did little to ease The amazing Spider ManThe dependency of the formula. Despite being released in 2012, The amazing Spider Man it had more in common with generic ’90s superhero movies. The amazing Spider Man it only got by on nostalgia, but it’s still better than its transparently cynical sequel.
6/10 Fantastic Four (2005) and Fantastic Four: Rise Of The Silver Surfer can’t stand on their own
the Fantastic four Some viewers consider the duology a nostalgic childhood favorite. The praise from fans is not entirely unfounded. Fantastic four Y The Rise of the Silver Surfer it featured solid casts and genuinely funny moments. However, they’re only good when contrasted against their universally maligned reboot, Fantastic.
Fantastic four Y The Rise of the Silver Surfer they’re lackluster movies that embodied the flaws of their 2000s genre. Worse, they failed to properly balance the team’s superhero adventures with their everyday lives. Even compared to other superhero outings from the same era, the two Fantastic four movies don’t hold up.
5/10 Flash Gordon was an acquired taste
flash gordon bombed in 1980 because its brand of superhero adventure was too cheesy and old-fashioned for viewers at the time. Decades later, flash gordon it found a passionate fan base who loved it for the same reasons it failed. Despite flash gordon It really is an underrated cheesy guilty pleasure, not for everyone.
even ignoring flash gordon‘scamp, it’s still a tonally muddled mess. The film was unsure if it was a direct adaptation of the old Flash Gordon series or a parody of one. flash gordon‘sthe most dedicated fans found a genuine and ironic joy in the film. To almost everyone else flash gordon It’s an inside joke that they just don’t get.
4/10 Kick-Ass & Kick-Ass 2 weren’t as transgressive as they claimed to be
the Kick ass The movies were considered a breath of fresh air in the 2010s because of how cutting edge they were. Truly, Kick ass Y kick ass 2 they are confident, almost toothless adaptations of notoriously self-indulgent comics. Worse still, the Kick ass movies weren’t sure whether to condemn superhero power fantasies or reaffirm them.
Each superhero critique was followed by a thrilling but jarringly violent action scene. Worse still, the Kick ass the movies backed down every time they had a chance to do something truly disturbing yet appropriately subversive. This thematic and tonal indecision became more acute Kick ass‘ an already juvenile and superficial satire.
3/10 Batman Forever was only passable at best
batman forever is seen by its advocates as the perfect balance of batman returns‘ Y batman and robin‘s styles that also starred a great cast, especially its villains. Nevertheless, batman forever it only got a pass because it was released right in the middle of its cult-favorite predecessor and a classic so bad it’s good.
Itself, batman forever it was a useful but disposable film. batman forever lacked the creativity of the two preceding bat Man movies and even batman and robinThe polarizing but unforgettable camp. The overacted interactions of the Riddler and Two-Face are the only parts of batman forever that is worth remembering.
2/10 Wanted a generic power fantasy
Dear it may lack any of the supervillain trappings of its original comic, but it’s still a superhero movie. Dear followed the journey of the traditional superhero and replaced the superpowers of the comics with impeccable assassination skills. these facts Dear one of the most popular action movies of 2008 that also had a strong cast.
Dear‘sThe biggest problem was not being an adaptation in name only, but being too safe. like comic, Dear it was a youthful power fantasy that combined cruelty with self-actualization. Nevertheless, Dear it took away the riotous edge of the comics, making it less interesting in hindsight. Dear it is now only remembered for its curved bullets.
1/10 Glass’s superhero deconstruction was outdated
Unbreakable Y Pull apart are two of the best R-rated and original superhero movies of the 2000s, and Glass it was his end. Glass it was a satisfying reward for the dangling threads of his predecessors. Glass It worked as an ambitious, nostalgic crossover for two standalone films, but fell short as a superhero deconstruction.
Glass’ deconstruction boiled down to little more than pointing out character archetypes and the tropes they’re meant to obey. When Glass hit theaters, superhero movies either addressed these points or made fun of them as dead pool made. Glass It worked as an ending, but it wasn’t as innovative as what came before.
NEXT: 10 Good Movies Ruined By A Bad Twist